Washington: In her speech accepting the Democratic nomination, Hillary Clinton wrongly implied Donald Trump has proposed banning Islam in America and sketched out a plan for defeating Islamic State terrorists that merely mirrors what the US is already trying to do.
Clinton spoke on Thursday night to the largest TV audience she is likely to have until the presidential debates, meaning many Americans were probably hearing of her agenda for the first time. Although she brings plenty of policy detail when stacked against the broad-brush ideas of her Republican rival, in some cases there's less than meets the eye to what she says she will do.
A college education, for example, might not end up as debt-free for everyone as she suggested.
A look at some of the claims made by the first woman democratic presidential nominee:
Hillary Clinton: "I've laid out my strategy for defeating ISIS. We will strike their sanctuaries from the air, and support local forces taking them out on the ground. We will surge our intelligence so that we detect and prevent attacks before they happen. We will disrupt their efforts online to reach and radicalise young people in our country. It won't be easy or quick, but make no mistake - we will prevail."
THE FACT: Clinton might as well have said she laid out President Barack Obama's strategy for defeating Islamic State terrorists. Everything she mentioned, the Obama administration already is trying to do.
___
Hillary Clinton: "Bernie Sanders and I will work together to make college tuition-free for the middle class and debt-free for all."
THE FACT: Tuition-free for students who go to an in-state public college or university. Debt-free is a harder lift.
Clinton has adopted parts of Sanders' plans to defray some of the costs of higher education. Under her proposal, the government would pay for tuition at in-state colleges and universities for students from families earning less than $125,000 a year. That would leave students still bearing the cost of room and board, which makes up more than half of the average $18,943 sticker price at a four-year public university, according to the College Board.
Experts worry about other impacts: Will colleges raise tuition once the government starts paying, increasing the cost to taxpayers? Will more students flock to public colleges because of the subsidy, also raising costs?
___
Hillary Clinton: "In my first 100 days, we will work with both parties to pass the biggest investment in new, good-paying jobs since World War II."
THE FACT: It would be the biggest since World War II only if you don't count Obama's $814 billion 2009 stimulus. Clinton doesn't have price tags on all her proposals, but the bulk of the investment appears to be her plan to spend $275 billion over five years on roads, bridges and other infrastructure. Obama's stimulus included infrastructure as well as tax cuts and aid to state and local governments, all intended to boost the economy and hiring.
___
Hillary Clinton: "We will not ban a religion."
THE FACT: Trump never proposed banning Islam in the US, as Clinton seems to suggest. He proposed a freeze on the entry of all foreign Muslims into the US, then adapted the idea with several iterations. Recently he said he'd stop immigration from any country compromised by terrorism, or impose "extreme vetting" on people coming from places with a history of terrorism. He's also spoken in support of surveillance on mosques in the US. As contentious as his thinking has been on the subject, it hasn't extended it to outlawing a religion.
___
Hillary Clinton on taxing the wealthy and corporations: "Because when more than 90% of the gains have gone to the top 1%, that's where the money is."
THE FACT: While vague, Clinton's claim probably relies on outdated figures and exaggerates inequality.
Her assertion echoes similar claims made by Sanders during the primary campaign, though it's not clear if she is referring to income or wealth or over what time frame. According to Emmanuel Saez, the University of California at Berkeley economist whose research on the wealthiest 1 percent helped spark the Occupy Wall Street protests, income gains have been more widely shared in recent years.
The top 1% captured 52% of the growth in incomes from 2009 through 2015, still a hefty amount. But that's down from the 2009 through 2012 period, when the top 1% captured 91% of the growth.
___
Hillary Clinton: "In Atlantic City, you'll find contractors and small businesses who lost everything because Donald Trump refused to pay his bills. People who did the work and needed the money, and didn't get it - not because he couldn't pay them, but because he wouldn't pay them."
THE FACT: Indeed, Trump casinos failed on several occasions. During the bankruptcy of the Taj Mahal Casino in the early 1990s, some contractors who'd helped Trump build the property went bust because Trump's company didn't pay what it owed them. Trump himself was short on cash at the time, though his bankers did give him a $450,000-a-month allowance to maintain his lifestyle while his debts were renegotiated.
Comments
0 comment